AIP Thanksgiving recipes keep the holiday table while cutting the foods the Autoimmune Protocol removes for 30 to 90 days: grains, dairy, eggs, nuts, seeds, nightshades, and refined sugar. Turkey is naturally AIP, and most sides need only a swap or two, so one menu serves the whole table.
Thanksgiving is the hardest holiday on AIP, because nearly every classic dish breaks a rule. Stuffing has bread, gravy has flour, mashed potatoes are nightshades, and pumpkin pie has eggs, butter, and nutmeg. The fixes below are small and tested, and they keep the meal recognizable.
This is a menu plan, not a single recipe. Each section gives one dish with its AIP swap spelled out, so you can build the whole meal or take the dishes you need. The lead recipe at the center of the menu is roasted sweet potatoes and Brussels sprouts, a side that is AIP exactly as written.
What you can eat on Thanksgiving on AIP
AIP is a temporary elimination plan, formalized by Sarah Ballantyne, PhD, in The Paleo Approach in 2014. The elimination phase runs about 30 to 90 days, then foods come back one at a time. It is not a permanent way of eating, and Thanksgiving falls inside it for many people.
At the table, the rules are simple. Turkey is naturally compliant, so the bird needs no change beyond its seasoning. Most sides need one or two swaps: butter becomes coconut oil or olive oil, flour becomes cassava flour or arrowroot, and white potatoes become sweet potatoes, cauliflower, or parsnips.
Watch the small things, since they are where AIP trips people up. Black pepper, paprika, nutmeg, and cumin are all out, and jarred pumpkin pie spice is out too, because it contains nutmeg. Green beans are a legume, so they belong to reintroduction stage 1, not strict elimination. For the full food list, see the AIP food list at Ivy Herbal, and for the general AIP guide, see our AIP diet recipes article.

Classic Thanksgiving dishes and their AIP swaps
Nearly every classic dish has an AIP version, and the swap is usually one ingredient. The table below covers the dishes that cause the most trouble, with the exact replacement that keeps them compliant.
| Classic dish | Problem ingredient | AIP swap |
|---|---|---|
| Stuffing | Wheat bread and eggs | Egg-free cassava biscuit cubes |
| Gravy | Flour and butter | Blended vegetables or arrowroot, turkey fat |
| Mashed potatoes | White potato, butter, milk | Mashed cauliflower, rutabaga, or parsnips with coconut cream |
| Pumpkin pie spice | Nutmeg | Mace, 1 to 1 for nutmeg |
| Pie crust | Wheat flour, butter, eggs | Tapioca and coconut flour crust with gelatin |
| Green bean casserole | Green beans, cream soup | Roasted Brussels sprouts, or green beans only in reintroduction |
| Black pepper seasoning | Black pepper | Dried ginger, cinnamon, fresh herbs |
| Almond flour bakes | Almond flour | Tigernut flour or cassava flour |
| Sweetener | Refined sugar | Honey or maple syrup, in small amounts |
| Cranberry sauce | Refined sugar | Honey, orange, and cinnamon |
Your complete AIP Thanksgiving menu
One pick per course keeps the cooking manageable. Every dish below is AIP in the elimination phase, except where noted, and the whole menu feeds eight with the turkey as the center.
| Course | Dish | Make ahead |
|---|---|---|
| Appetizer | Roasted cauliflower garlic dip with sweet potato chips | Day before |
| Main | Roast turkey with herb butter, no pepper | Season day before |
| Gravy | Blended vegetable gravy from pan drippings | Day of, 10 minutes |
| Stuffing | Cassava biscuit stuffing with sausage and sage | Bake day of |
| Side | Roasted sweet potatoes and Brussels sprouts | Prep day before |
| Side | Mashed cauliflower and parsnips | Day of |
| Side | Honey cranberry sauce | 3 days before |
| Dessert | Gelatin-set pumpkin pie with tigernut crust | Day before |
| Drink | Warm spiced apple cider, no alcohol | Day of |
Appetizers
Start with something that needs no explaining. A roasted cauliflower garlic dip, blended smooth with olive oil and lemon, sits next to sweet potato chips and raw vegetables. It is AIP as written, and guests who are not on AIP will not notice the difference.
Keep appetizers to one or two dishes. The point is to buy time while the turkey rests, not to fill everyone up before dinner. A simple plate of olives, sliced cucumber, and roasted squash bites with bacon covers it.
Make the dip the day before, since the garlic flavor gets better overnight. Set out the chips and vegetables in a wide bowl so guests serve themselves, and keep the dip away from the bread basket so no crumbs fall in.
Turkey and gravy
The turkey needs almost no change. Roast it plain with olive oil, salt, rosemary, thyme, and sage, and skip the black pepper and paprika in the rub. The bird itself is naturally AIP, and the seasoning is where most recipes go wrong.
For a small table, a breast beats a whole bird. Our turkey breast recipe roasts in about two hours and feeds eight, and the same herb butter method works for a 3 pound boneless breast. Make the gravy from the pan drippings, blended with roasted vegetables or thickened with arrowroot, instead of a flour roux.
Stuffing
Stuffing is the dish that needs the most work, because bread and eggs are both out. The AIP version starts with egg-free cassava biscuits, baked a day ahead, cut into cubes, and dried in the oven. Cassava flour swaps close to 1 to 1 for wheat flour, so the texture stays familiar.
Cook the cubes with homemade sausage, onion, celery, sage, thyme, rosemary, and dried ginger in place of pepper. Moisten with bone broth and bake until the top crisps. It tastes like stuffing, not like a substitute, and it is the dish guests ask about most.
Side dishes
Sides are where AIP Thanksgiving shines, because most vegetables are already compliant. Roasted vegetables, mashed roots, and cranberry sauce need small swaps, not new recipes, and they carry the meal when the turkey is plain.
Roasted sweet potatoes and Brussels sprouts
This is the lead dish of the menu, and it is AIP exactly as written. Sweet potatoes are allowed, since they are not nightshades, and Brussels sprouts, cranberries, honey, and olive oil are all on the elimination list. The honey caramelizes the edges, and the cranberries go tart against the sweet potato.
Cut the sweet potatoes into even cubes so they cook at the same rate as the sprouts. Roast at 400 degrees until the edges brown, then toss in the cranberries and honey for the last 10 minutes so they soften without burning.
Prep time: 15 minutes
Cook time: 35 minutes
Serves: 6
Ingredients
- 2 pounds sweet potatoes, peeled and cut into 1 inch cubes
- 1 pound Brussels sprouts, trimmed and halved
- 1 cup fresh cranberries
- 2 tablespoons honey
- 2 tablespoons olive oil
- 1 tablespoon chopped fresh rosemary
- 1 teaspoon sea salt
Steps
- Heat the oven to 400 degrees. Line a large sheet pan with parchment paper.
- Toss the sweet potatoes and Brussels sprouts with the olive oil, rosemary, and salt.
- Spread in a single layer and roast 25 minutes, until the edges start to brown.
- Add the cranberries and drizzle the honey over the pan. Toss gently.
- Roast 10 minutes more, until the sweet potatoes are tender and the cranberries soften.
- Serve warm, with the pan juices spooned over the top.
One serving works out to about 231 calories, counted from USDA FoodData Central values for the sweet potatoes, Brussels sprouts, cranberries, honey, and olive oil. Sweet potatoes are 86 calories per 100 grams, Brussels sprouts 43, cranberries 46, honey 304, and olive oil 884.

Mashed cauliflower and parsnips
White potatoes are nightshades, so mashed potatoes are out, but mashed cauliflower and parsnips fill the same spot on the plate. Steam them until soft, then blend with coconut cream, olive oil, garlic, and salt until smooth. The parsnips add the sweetness that potatoes usually bring.
Cranberry sauce
Cranberry sauce is AIP as written once the sugar is swapped. Simmer fresh cranberries with water, honey, orange zest, and a cinnamon stick until they burst, then cool. It sets on its own, it keeps for a week in the fridge, and it is the easiest dish on the whole menu.
Green bean casserole, with a note
Green beans are a legume, so they are reintroduction stage 1, not strict elimination. If you are past that stage, a green bean casserole works with a homemade mushroom sauce and a tigernut flour topping. If you are still in elimination, use roasted Brussels sprouts in the same spot on the plate.
Desserts without eggs or nuts
Dessert is the hardest course on AIP, because eggs and nuts hold most holiday baking together. The fix is gelatin, which sets a pumpkin pie without eggs, and tigernut flour, which makes a crust without nuts. Tigernuts are a tuber, not a nut, so they are allowed.
A gelatin-set pumpkin pie uses a tapioca and coconut flour crust, pumpkin puree, coconut milk, honey, cinnamon, ginger, and mace in place of nutmeg. Chill it overnight so the gelatin firms up, and serve it with coconut whipped cream. An apple crisp with a tigernut flour topping works the same way, and it bakes in half the time.
For guests who are not on AIP, our pumpkin dessert recipes cover the classic versions, so the table can hold both. Label the AIP dishes clearly, and keep the AIP pie on its own plate so nobody mixes up the slices.

Drinks
Alcohol and coffee are both out during elimination, so the drink table needs a rethink. Warm spiced apple cider, simmered with cinnamon sticks, orange slices, and cloves, is the easiest pick, and it smells like the holiday while it cooks.
Sparkling water with cranberry juice and rosemary makes a simple mocktail, and green or black tea is allowed on AIP. Put the drinks where guests can serve themselves, so no one has to ask what is safe.
Skip the mulled wine and the eggnog, since alcohol, dairy, and nutmeg are all out. A pot of herbal tea with honey on the side gives guests something warm to hold after dinner, and it needs no recipe at all.
Make-ahead timeline
AIP cooking takes longer than standard cooking, because most dishes start from scratch. A timeline keeps the day calm and the oven free for the turkey.
| When | Do this |
|---|---|
| 1 week out | Order cassava flour, tigernut flour, arrowroot, coconut aminos, and gelatin |
| 3 days out | Make cranberry sauce, bake cassava biscuits for stuffing, chill the pie crust |
| Day before | Season the turkey, cube the stuffing bread, prep vegetables, make the pie |
| Thanksgiving morning | Turkey in the oven, stuffing assembled, cider on the stove |
| Day of, last hour | Roast vegetables, mash cauliflower, make gravy from drippings |
Store-bought shortcuts and label checks
Not everything has to be homemade. Canned pumpkin, coconut aminos, cassava flour baking mixes, and canned coconut milk save hours, and they are AIP when the label is clean. Buy the shortcuts early, since holiday stock runs out fast.
Read every label, because pepper, paprika, seed oils, and gums hide in broths, spice blends, and sauces. Most store-bought broths are not AIP, so make bone broth at home or buy one that lists only bones, water, and salt. If a label lists an ingredient you do not recognize, skip it.
Baking mixes made for AIP, like cassava flatbread mix for dressing or a sugar cookie mix for pie crusts, save the most time. Check that the mix has no nut flour and no seed spices, and bake a test batch before the holiday so there are no surprises.
Hosting a mixed table
Most AIP cooks are feeding people who are not on AIP, and one menu can serve both. Roast one turkey for everyone, since it is naturally compliant, and make the sides AIP so nobody needs a separate plate. The swaps in this menu are invisible to guests who are not looking for them.
Label the AIP dishes with small cards, and put the non-AIP dishes on the far side of the table so the AIP plate stays safe. If you are a guest at someone else’s table, bring one dish you can eat and a dessert, and tell the host ahead of time. That is easier than explaining the whole diet at the door.
For the standard versions of these dishes, our Thanksgiving sides roundup covers the classics, and our special diet recipes collection covers other restricted diets for mixed tables. For snacking while the turkey rests, gluten free snacks like air popped corn chips keep everyone happy.
What to do with leftovers
Leftovers are the easiest part of AIP Thanksgiving, because the turkey and vegetables keep well. Simmer the carcass with water, onion, and herbs for bone broth, which becomes soup for the rest of the week.
Shred leftover turkey into soup with sweet potato and carrots, or into a hash with roasted vegetables. Once eggs are back in reintroduction, a fried egg on top turns the hash into breakfast.
Refrigerate leftovers within two hours, keep them 3 to 4 days, and freeze what you will not eat by then.
Frequently asked questions
Is pumpkin pie AIP compliant?
Only with an egg-free, grain-free, nut-free crust and a gelatin-set filling. Use a tapioca and coconut flour crust, pumpkin puree, coconut milk, honey, cinnamon, ginger, and mace in place of nutmeg. Jarred pumpkin pie spice is not AIP, because it contains nutmeg.
Can you eat mashed potatoes on AIP?
No, white potatoes are nightshades, so they are out during elimination. Mashed cauliflower, rutabaga, or parsnips with coconut cream fill the same spot on the plate.
How do you make AIP gravy without flour?
Blend roasted vegetables with the pan drippings until smooth, or thicken the drippings with arrowroot starch. Use turkey fat instead of butter, and skip the flour roux entirely.
Is coffee AIP compliant?
No, coffee is a seed, so it is removed during elimination and comes back in reintroduction stage 3. Green and black tea are allowed, and warm spiced apple cider is the easiest holiday drink.



